urbanite take

A Chicagoan opines on land use, transportation and the walkable city

D&L6: Chicago neighborhoods: sparking parties, secession and uproar since 1832

with 3 comments

Chapter 6. The use of city neighborhoods

While the preceding and following chapters — especially the following five  — are focused largely on design and sidewalk life, “The use of city neighborhoods” examines these building blocks” roles in self-government. Jacobs asserts that there are functionally only three types of city neighborhoods: the city as a whole, individual city streets and “districts,” which serve the role of mediating between the individual city street and the city government as a whole.

The word “neighborhood” must be one of the most-used words in urban planning, history and sociology. Whole books examine the subject; Chicago, along with many other cities, likes to call itself a “city of neighborhoods.” I’m not well-versed in analyzing political power of city districts, which this chapter really strays into, but I’ve been able to perceive a lot of the power that the idea of “neighborhood” has.

People are fascinated with knowing neighborhood boundaries. Chicago has 77 “community areas,” which have remained unchanged since the 1920s when they were drawn by University of Chicago researchers; they’re used to this day as a basis for comparisons and statistics. While some, like West Town, comprise what almost everyone would think of as several separate neighborhoods (Logan Square, Wicker Park, Bucktown), other community areas such as Edgewater clearly coincide with what most Chicagoans would think of as one neighborhood — this last community area in fact separated from the Uptown community area in a rare secession in the 1970s.

I always feel like I can perceive street neighborhoods the most clearly visualized during the summer when there are seemingly millions of street festivals — Chicago’s highly regular grid results in major streets every half-mile (with a number of exceptions), and there are often half-mile or three-quarter-mile long festivals all the time.

One of my favorite websites, Every Block, allows you to enter your address and you get local news, which is sorted by a variety of different designations; variously by ward, ZIP code, neighborhood, community area, address). While some of these, such as ZIP code, aren’t really functional mental decisions — do you think of yourself as a resident of your ZIP/postal code? with few exceptions à la 90210, you probably don’t — it does make you think about the groupings in which you see yourself.

Jacobs mentions that “the first relationships to form in city areas” are often among local civic organizations, such as civic leagues, PTAs, political clubs, etc. I do wonder if in our modern-day age, with higher rates of Internet usage and declines in traditional club membership, if this still holds true in our day.

Certainly, people still come together when they feel the neighborhood is being split. Chicago recently finished a contentious redistricting of its ward boundaries, and the Lincoln Park neighborhood — one of the most well-heeled in the city — rose up when it looked like it might be split between different wards of the city, when it had previously all been under one, in the 43rd ward.

Among all the concepts of the “city,” city neighborhoods seem to inspire a great deal of enthusiasm, energy, vitriol and criticism. And you can do endless research on getting people to find out what neighborhood city people live in. Jacobs’ appraisal on civic organizations may not entirely reflect current reality, but I think the fundamental importance of the city neighborhood still rings true.

Written by Andrew ACG

February 21, 2012 at 8:00 am

Posted in Uncategorized

3 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I’m a huge fan of Every Block – I don’t check it as often because the East Village (where I work and spend a lot of time in) is served by another fantastic site, EV Grieve (http://evgrieve.com/). It’s a simple blog that updates frequently with short posts about the buildings, streets, parks, people, etc. in the neighborhood – often with user submitted content. I definitely feel more connected to and invested in the well being of the East Village as a result. It’s funny that we may never know our neighbors, but the internet enables me to have a bond with all the nameless and faceless residents in the area who also same neighborhood identity without being part of community boards and other local civic orgs.


    February 21, 2012 at 1:05 pm

  2. Whoops didn’t edit before posting. Please excuse grammatical errors/missing words 😉


    February 21, 2012 at 1:19 pm

  3. […] A City Guy (Chicago, USA) on Chapter 6: Chicago neighborhoods: sparking parties, secession and uproar since 1832 […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: